Board Game Geek
Recent Additions
Reply: General Role-Playing:: Re: QOTD NOV 19: How important is the concept of Balance in an RPG to you? What does Balance mean to you, and what needs or does not need to be balanced in an RPG?
Posted: Thu, 19 Nov 20:56:35
Posted: Thu, 19 Nov 20:56:35
by latindog
I am not particularly concerned with issues of balance as long as everyone at the table is able to actively participate and feel relevant. In combat heavy games, odd situations can arise if the party's composition is off. I ran a lengthy Pathfinder 2e campaign in which the players were running a bunch of support based, defensive characters including a witch, an oracle, a cleric, a bard and an alchemist. We had one frontline fighter but very little ability to do massive amounts of damage in one fell swoop (the alchemist had some effective bombs in the early levels but these tapered off in power as they gained levels). Combat encounters at higher levels were sooooo loooong because of this - lots of clever tricks to nerf things, heal and shield but the occasional fireball or something would have helped matters out. I did my best to speed things along but it was tough to run big combats with this group RAW.
GeekList Item: Item for GeekList "How Do I Check For Board Game Deals?"
Posted: Thu, 19 Nov 20:54:52
Posted: Thu, 19 Nov 20:54:52
by B2TB
An item Board Game Publisher: Ravensburger AG has been added to the geeklist How Do I Check For Board Game Deals?
Reply: General Role-Playing:: Re: QOTD NOV 19: How important is the concept of Balance in an RPG to you? What does Balance mean to you, and what needs or does not need to be balanced in an RPG?
Posted: Thu, 19 Nov 20:31:16
I think the reason you see it more in drop-in games is that in a campaign you can tailor the experience to the players' skills. You can deliberately put in challenges that certain characters will use to seize the spotlight and be awesome. There's a lot less scope for that in a one-shot.
Posted: Thu, 19 Nov 20:31:16
by robbbbbb
SeaofStars wrote:
I do not care about mechanical balance except as so far as one player's build make another players experience less satisfying and less fun. If a players feels their character's purpose has been turfed out by another player's character build, then there is a problem. This is more something that happened in open drop in games than campaigns in my experience. But I admit the though that I had bulit such a character by accident was highly distresing in a recent Shadowrun mission.
I think the reason you see it more in drop-in games is that in a campaign you can tailor the experience to the players' skills. You can deliberately put in challenges that certain characters will use to seize the spotlight and be awesome. There's a lot less scope for that in a one-shot.
Reply: General Role-Playing:: Re: QOTD NOV 19: How important is the concept of Balance in an RPG to you? What does Balance mean to you, and what needs or does not need to be balanced in an RPG?
Posted: Thu, 19 Nov 20:27:14
Posted: Thu, 19 Nov 20:27:14
by SeaofStars
I do not care about mechanical balance except as so far as one player's build make another players experience less satisfying and less fun. If a players feels their character's purpose has been turfed out by another player's character build, then there is a problem. This is more something that happened in open drop in games than campaigns in my experience. But I admit the though that I had bulit such a character by accident was highly distresing in a recent Shadowrun mission.
Reply: General Role-Playing:: Re: QOTD OCT 31: What mechanic from one RPG has permanently changed how you run or play other games?
Posted: Thu, 19 Nov 20:22:20
I loved not knowing myself, because I couldn’t give away their status accidentally or otherwise. I also loved seeing player behaviour. Some would shake the cup to change their potential fate. Others would take it as it came.
I have played games with friends that definitely would not allow shaking the cup in a situation like that. (The same kind of player that can get upset if someone shuffles a deck of cards an extra time at some random point during a boardgame, since it changes the deck so that the next card drawn will likely not be what it ought to have been!)
Posted: Thu, 19 Nov 20:22:20
by pelni
leroy43 wrote:
I loved not knowing myself, because I couldn’t give away their status accidentally or otherwise. I also loved seeing player behaviour. Some would shake the cup to change their potential fate. Others would take it as it came.
I have played games with friends that definitely would not allow shaking the cup in a situation like that. (The same kind of player that can get upset if someone shuffles a deck of cards an extra time at some random point during a boardgame, since it changes the deck so that the next card drawn will likely not be what it ought to have been!)
New comment on Item for GeekList "[US] RPGG Pay It Forward: Traditional List"
Posted: Thu, 19 Nov 19:54:20
Posted: Thu, 19 Nov 19:54:20
by Bahasa
Related Item: Pathfinder Roleplaying Game (2nd Edition)
One of the reasons I love DCC is PC creation can be seconds (using Purple Sorcerer) or minutes, but the system allows players to do what they want without requiring specific skills (at level 1+). So a Warrior and Dwarf come up with a Mighty deed each time they attack and they don't need to have cleave, greater cleave, etc. if they want to hit multiple enemies (the deed die does need to meet a 3 or higher though).
Reply: General Role-Playing:: Re: QOTD OCT 31: What mechanic from one RPG has permanently changed how you run or play other games?
Posted: Thu, 19 Nov 19:51:14
I loved not knowing myself, because I couldn’t give away their status accidentally or otherwise. I also loved seeing player behaviour. Some would shake the cup to change their potential fate. Others would take it as it came.
But I loved not knowing. This weekend I’m running an adventure where one specific character may be human, maybe not, and I’m going to randomly give them a card that says which they are. Part of the adventure is finding out that there are non-humans in the crew and I’ll find out at the same time.
Posted: Thu, 19 Nov 19:51:14
by leroy43
In Mothership, when you take your final wound, the Warden rolls a die under a cup and slides it over to the player. Nobody, including the Warden, knows the outcome until someone runs over to check them out.I loved not knowing myself, because I couldn’t give away their status accidentally or otherwise. I also loved seeing player behaviour. Some would shake the cup to change their potential fate. Others would take it as it came.
But I loved not knowing. This weekend I’m running an adventure where one specific character may be human, maybe not, and I’m going to randomly give them a card that says which they are. Part of the adventure is finding out that there are non-humans in the crew and I’ll find out at the same time.
GeekList Item: Item for GeekList "Dan's Basic D&D 'Keep on the Borderlands' game"
Posted: Thu, 19 Nov 19:46:42
Posted: Thu, 19 Nov 19:46:42
by wysire
An item RPG Item: Thief of Kasar has been added to the geeklist Dan's Basic D&D 'Keep on the Borderlands' game
New comment on Blog Post Jan Hammer - Windows
Posted: Thu, 19 Nov 19:41:13
Posted: Thu, 19 Nov 19:41:13
by hankheyming
Related Item: Do you hear me? Do you care?
Interesting, for some reason I always thought Jan Hammer was a he. No idea why, maybe my brain read Ian or I figured he/she was dutch or something. Chill music. Way better than Enya...
Thread: Robert E. Howard's Conan: Adventures in an Age Undreamed Of:: Play By Forum:: The Thousand Eyes of Aumag-Bel [OOC]
Posted: Thu, 19 Nov 19:27:00
Posted: Thu, 19 Nov 19:27:00
Konye is a bustling mercantile city in the north of Argos, located where the Road of Kings crosses a couple of other trade routes.
When you get here, you Carouse. Take a look at the Carousing section in the Core Rules (pp 288 to 295) and then roll a Carousing Event for your character (pp295 et seq) on 2d20.
When you get here, you Carouse. Take a look at the Carousing section in the Core Rules (pp 288 to 295) and then roll a Carousing Event for your character (pp295 et seq) on 2d20.




