Roll 3d6 - Roleplaying Resources

Board Game Geek

Recent Additions

 The Great ACKS II Retrospective
Posted: Mon, 23 Mar 23:09:27
A new episode has been added to the database: The Great ACKS II Retrospective
 Decay: Session 0 (Part 1) - Community Creation
Posted: Mon, 23 Mar 23:08:46
A new episode has been added to the database: Decay: Session 0 (Part 1) - Community Creation
 Scryfall Roulette w/ The Spike Feeders || TTC Ep592
Posted: Mon, 23 Mar 23:08:15
A new episode has been added to the database: Scryfall Roulette w/ The Spike Feeders || TTC Ep592
 FBL s07e10 "Back to the Arina Forest"
Posted: Mon, 23 Mar 23:06:12
A new episode has been added to the database: FBL s07e10 "Back to the Arina Forest"
 Episode 615: Elf, Sea - Dimernesti to Fetch
Posted: Mon, 23 Mar 23:05:51
A new episode has been added to the database: Episode 615: Elf, Sea - Dimernesti to Fetch
 Reply: RPGGeek News:: Re: Geek Citizenship Recognition
Posted: Mon, 23 Mar 22:34:32

by BG05

Congrats to everyone! Keep doing great things!

I am one star away from having them all. I hope you all continue to rack up more stars!!!
 New comment on Item for GeekList "Kickstarter RPG Game Books - 2026"
Posted: Mon, 23 Mar 22:32:32

by brumcg

Related Item: Stone Fable

chuckdee68 wrote:

What explains this projects sprint out of the gate?


Hrm. Probably this?

William is a content creator with a combined following of over 500,000 fans on Instagram Facebook and TikTok. Known for sinister sketches extending well-known nursery rhymes and superstitions which have seen viral success and millions of views.

 Reply: General Role-Playing:: Re: QOTD MAR 23: What is the difference between a fairy tale creature and a fantasy creature? How does a creature, such as an goblin or elf, that exists as both creature types differ or remain the same?
Posted: Mon, 23 Mar 22:23:31

by xeirwn

The fairy versions are mysterious, they have unknown qualities to us... Or even unknowable.

They are something other.

The RPG versions anthropomorphise them. Thus more often than not, they lose their otherness, their mystique and their allure.

Once you have anthropomorphised an elf, or turned a stern frightful Germanic Kobold that looks like an old man into a d&D kobold which is very different. Then you have to look for some other creature that is unknown/other/mysterious. And constantly retcon it into the setting - a technique that doesn't feel very effective to me, and results in a kitchen sink feeling.

I prefer settings that preserve that mystique of the source material as much as possible. Otherwise why include them, if you're going to trivialise them? I think it has to do with the impulse to fill in all the blanks. When you do that, the mystery disappears.
It's harder to keep them like that in an RPG admittedly - can a player portray an other? Do they even want to? The easier way is to keep them out of reach of players. But it all depends on what's your end goal.