Board Game Geek
Recent Additions
Reply: General Role-Playing:: Re: QOTD SEP 17: Do you like games that reward system mastery? What about setting mastery? Why or why not?
Posted: Thu, 17 Sep 14:33:05
We've always gone by if a rule needs to be looked up only give it a minute of searching, otherwise the GM can make a ruling then look up the rule after the session to apply going forward.
If a Player shows evidence of knowing the rules in Paranoia (Mongoose Edition) then that's grounds for Treason against The COMPUTER! 😄
Posted: Thu, 17 Sep 14:33:05
by Ugavine
If you mean by knowing all the games rules, well that can certainly help as a GM. Players don't necessarily need to know everything. But it is not always necessary, and sometimes nearly impossible. Imagine trying to learn every rule introduced throughout all the Advanced Dungeons & Dragons (2nd Edition) modules!We've always gone by if a rule needs to be looked up only give it a minute of searching, otherwise the GM can make a ruling then look up the rule after the session to apply going forward.
If a Player shows evidence of knowing the rules in Paranoia (Mongoose Edition) then that's grounds for Treason against The COMPUTER! 😄
New comment on GeekList #61 Polski MatHandel (Polish Math Trade)
Posted: Thu, 17 Sep 14:32:42
Posted: Thu, 17 Sep 14:32:42
by Bananeq
Jakby ktoś był chętny na coś to zapraszam do kontaktu ;)
Reply: General Role-Playing:: Re: QOTD SEP 17: Do you like games that reward system mastery? What about setting mastery? Why or why not?
Posted: Thu, 17 Sep 14:20:34
I'm usually the system expert at the table, especially when I'm GM. I can manage the game system for the players if I have to. However, I find it really rewarding when my players take the time to engage with the game part of the system well enough that I don't have to worry about them. Then I can play the game against them. That is, I can set up scenarios and the game bits of the RPG become a contest for both sides. That's super-rewarding as a GM.
Posted: Thu, 17 Sep 14:20:34
by robbbbbb
I do like games that reward system mastery. After all, the hobby is about role playing games. You're playing a game, so getting good at the game-playing part is important.I'm usually the system expert at the table, especially when I'm GM. I can manage the game system for the players if I have to. However, I find it really rewarding when my players take the time to engage with the game part of the system well enough that I don't have to worry about them. Then I can play the game against them. That is, I can set up scenarios and the game bits of the RPG become a contest for both sides. That's super-rewarding as a GM.
Reply: General Role-Playing:: Re: QOTD SEP 11: What do you think of GMs offering suggested courses of action to the players? As a GM, when do & don't you do this? How many options? As a player, do you like when GMs do this?
Posted: Thu, 17 Sep 14:12:52
Thank you for this great advice. I GMed last night and tried counting silently to 10 before butting in with suggestions. It worked really well! My players definitely had thoughts and ideas that came out. I was mistaking their silence as not having ideas but I think they're trying not to talk over each other or are more introverted. Thanks again!
Posted: Thu, 17 Sep 14:12:52
by Serpentine_C
VolcanoLotus wrote:
I think it’s well worth the awkwardness to get used to dead air, especially online.
Thank you for this great advice. I GMed last night and tried counting silently to 10 before butting in with suggestions. It worked really well! My players definitely had thoughts and ideas that came out. I was mistaking their silence as not having ideas but I think they're trying not to talk over each other or are more introverted. Thanks again!
Reply: The Last Ember:: Reviews:: Re: The Last Ember Review
Posted: Thu, 17 Sep 14:09:05
Posted: Thu, 17 Sep 14:09:05
Hi Damdael,
Thank you for taking the time to play through The Last Ember and write such a detailed review. I’m sorry the experience was disappointing, and that your physical copy arrived damaged.
Your examples of unclear rules, confusing paragraph links, continuity problems, and print-layout issues give us specific things to work through. Your broader point about the presentation getting in the way of the story is something we need to take seriously, too. You should be able to enjoy the adventure without having to untangle its instructions.
We will go back through the book and give it a thorough re-edit, using your review to help guide that work. This will include checking the adventure’s routes and references, clarifying the rules where they are used, and reviewing the layout and readability of the printed edition. Once the revision is complete, we will send the updated book to all backers.
Thank you for backing the project and for being candid about where it fell short. We owe you and our other backers a better experience.
Matthew
Thank you for taking the time to play through The Last Ember and write such a detailed review. I’m sorry the experience was disappointing, and that your physical copy arrived damaged.
Your examples of unclear rules, confusing paragraph links, continuity problems, and print-layout issues give us specific things to work through. Your broader point about the presentation getting in the way of the story is something we need to take seriously, too. You should be able to enjoy the adventure without having to untangle its instructions.
We will go back through the book and give it a thorough re-edit, using your review to help guide that work. This will include checking the adventure’s routes and references, clarifying the rules where they are used, and reviewing the layout and readability of the printed edition. Once the revision is complete, we will send the updated book to all backers.
Thank you for backing the project and for being candid about where it fell short. We owe you and our other backers a better experience.
Matthew
GeekList Item: Item for GeekList "Solo RPGs on Your Table - September 2026"
Posted: Thu, 17 Sep 14:00:20
Posted: Thu, 17 Sep 14:00:20
by Brass Jester
An item RPG Item: Ironsworn: Starforged has been added to the geeklist Solo RPGs on Your Table - September 2026
Dudes Brew Beer (Скуфы варят пиво PDF)
Posted: Thu, 17 Sep 13:58:30
Posted: Thu, 17 Sep 13:58:30
A new rpg item version has been added to the database:
Dudes Brew Beer (Скуфы варят пиво PDF)
Dudes Brew Beer
Posted: Thu, 17 Sep 13:58:30
Posted: Thu, 17 Sep 13:58:30
A new rpg item has been added to the database:
Dudes Brew Beer
Dudes Brew Beer (PDF Version)
Posted: Thu, 17 Sep 13:58:29
Posted: Thu, 17 Sep 13:58:29
A new rpg item version has been added to the database:
Dudes Brew Beer (PDF Version)
Dudes Brew Beer (Скуфы варят пиво)
Posted: Thu, 17 Sep 13:58:29
Posted: Thu, 17 Sep 13:58:29
A new rpg item version has been added to the database:
Dudes Brew Beer (Скуфы варят пиво)
Revised Giant Book of Battle Mats (Print Edition)
Posted: Thu, 17 Sep 13:58:21
Posted: Thu, 17 Sep 13:58:21
A new rpg item version has been added to the database:
Revised Giant Book of Battle Mats (Print Edition)
Revised Giant Book of Battle Mats
Posted: Thu, 17 Sep 13:58:21
Posted: Thu, 17 Sep 13:58:21
A new rpg item has been added to the database:
Revised Giant Book of Battle Mats



