Roll 3d6 - Roleplaying Resources

Board Game Geek

Recent Additions

 Product For Sale: Root the RPG: Core Rulebook
Posted: Mon, 16 Nov 16:50:51

by ShellBell

$37.00 for RPG Item: Root the RPG: Core Rulebook
Condition: Like New
Location: United States
 Reply: Game Masters:: Re: A case study in resolving a thorny "stealing from the party" incident
Posted: Mon, 16 Nov 16:47:14

by cosine

SteamCraft wrote:

I think this is a bit difficult from a lack of detail - did the thief manage to get far enough a way to pocket anything?


No. The thief would have moved from Near to Far, but players cast a spell to banish the posessing spirit before the thief got their action.

 Reply: Play by Forum:: Re: New Numenera Game
Posted: Mon, 16 Nov 16:46:54

by Mulligans

If love to join. I've run Numenera and other Cypher system games a bunch but almost never get the chance to be a player. I'll be able to do my own character building.
 Product For Sale: Avatar Legends: The Roleplaying Game Core Rulebook
Posted: Mon, 16 Nov 16:44:58

by ShellBell

$41.00 for RPG Item: Avatar Legends: The Roleplaying Game Core Rulebook
Condition: Like New
Location: United States
 Reply: Game Masters:: Re: A case study in resolving a thorny "stealing from the party" incident
Posted: Mon, 16 Nov 16:22:35

by Flyboy Connor

It depends on the parameters of the game established by the GM. In my games, if a player wants to have the opportunity to do things which they hide from the rest of the party, they have to tell me before the session starts (or at least before they do an action they would potentially want to keep secret). In that case, if they find something that could be a secret, I tell them alone, and they can decide what they share with the party.

However, I discourage this kind of behavior, as I forbid using Persuasion and Intimidation within the party (because I do not want to get into situation where players try to influence the actions of each others' characters). Deception is okay, though, so in principle this is still possible, but I don't like it if I cannot openly discuss things at the table. I am sure that my players could handle it, but it makes me feel funny.

Anyway, if I would get into a situation as described, I would, like you, make it depend on die rolls. In D&D, the thief would have to succeed on a Deception roll which I will pit against the Insight rolls of all other characters. In a CoC game, I would make it a Fast Talk roll against Psychology rolls. Could this lead to intra-party conflict? Maybe, but the thief could claim that his attempt to steal from the party was the result of the recent possession, to defuse the situation.

BTW, I don't think that "greed" is a good motivation to steal from the party. "Greed" is a good motivation to go after treasure incessantly. A motivation that would drive a player to make his character act against the party, I would disqualify up front.
 Reply: Game Masters:: Re: A case study in resolving a thorny "stealing from the party" incident
Posted: Mon, 16 Nov 16:19:58

by SteamCraft

I think this is a bit difficult from a lack of detail - did the thief manage to get far enough a way to pocket anything?

Lacking a plausible method of securing any loot without being seen, I just would have had the players RP it out. That is, the players would point out that they clearly saw the thief be possessed and run off with the loot. If the thief denies it, they could point out they all saw it.

I suppose such a situation would lead to conflict and potentially violence between the PCs. At the same time, if something is obvious I do not use rolls. At the same time, it is just a bit stupid to deny what happened in front of other players.

Your solution makes sense if there was a way the thief could have pocketed it without being noticed. In that case, I would have randomly determined how much. To me, if any party member saw it then they would have the option to point it out. That again would lead to interparty conflict.

I am fine with the thief steeling from the party - or even the other PCs. I think might issue is trying to play dumb when everyone saw you.
 Reply: Game Masters:: Re: A case study in resolving a thorny "stealing from the party" incident
Posted: Mon, 16 Nov 16:15:37

by Karkared

cosine wrote:

at the end of every session and you get bonus XP if you can convince me (GM) of how something you did during the session exemplified that motive. The thief's motive was "greed". (...) for each person the thief beat, we would say that his quick moves and chicanery had let him lighten the bags by 100gp each into a hidden pocket! He beat a few of the party members and secured extra loot for himself and "greed" XP later.


I like your solution. The minigame was fun it seems, but it could also have been reduced to "roll 1D6x100".
Another solution I see is to say that the thief gets points for trying. Regardless of the outcome, he did what his motive urged him to do. If your point is to make characters act in a certain way, then it is not his fault that he could not hide it. Losing the loot is already quite the punishement.
 Reply: General Role-Playing:: Re: RPGGeek 2026 Holiday Gift Exchange
Posted: Mon, 16 Nov 16:13:18

by tyrone_jones

yeah My budget says no, I wish I could, and I appreciate Auntie Olive in offering to help but knowing that this is voluntery and that it will go on without me I will decline this year. I still will follow the threads as I love seeing this kind of celebration. I just would hate to impose on someone like that. Thank you To Auntie Olive for the generous offer. You are a gem of the community!
 Reply: Game Masters:: Re: A case study in resolving a thorny "stealing from the party" incident
Posted: Mon, 16 Nov 16:04:52

by cosine

cosine wrote:


1. All the characters saw the thief with their own eyes take the two bags of loot.
2. The thief player was directly denying that reality to the other players.


If either party in this interaction had been NPCs, it would have been much easier. We'd just have a contested roll off similar to the above and let gods work it out. But here I was going to have to rule against one set of players or the other. It was lose / lose. But I really wanted to reward the over cautious thief player for rising to the occasion, but also avoid pissing off the others. In effect, I was trying to jump to a "negotiated" solution where each side got some of what they wanted. I set up a mechanism to avoid myself catching the blame of making a decision that skipped over the will of the players.
 Thread: Game Masters:: A case study in resolving a thorny "stealing from the party" incident
Posted: Mon, 16 Nov 15:55:43

by cosine

At this week's RPG night, we had an interesting hiccup in the game for which I am the GM. I will walk you through it, but would be interested to hear alternatives or reactions. This week's episode was filmed before a live Shadowdark audience and is titled "Holding the Bag".

Our heroes had just entered the main catacombs beneath a ruined city. The necromancer told everyone how he felt the looming presence of thousands of ghosts, the ethereal pressure of so many lives ended suddenly in the earthquake that destroyed the city. The characters came across a large white altar where traditionally the mortal remains of city residents would be given last rights and pass into custody of the lord of the dead.

The thief approached and looked for secret panels. A conceal panel was pushed aside to reveal two large bags of hacksilver, but before anyone could react, a possessing spirit took control of the thief and tried to run off with the loot. They banished the spirit and saved the thief.

And one player asked the thief player "What did you find?" To which the player of the thief responded glibly but sincerely, "Nothing." My DM danger sense began to tingle as interparty warfare seemed imminent.

See, we are playing with a house rule that you select a motive for your character and at the end of every session and you get bonus XP if you can convince me (GM) of how something you did during the session exemplified that motive. The thief's motive was "greed". He has missed getting bonus XP a couple of times because he is the sort of player that is loathe to take any risks or put their character forward. But here he was doing exactly what I hoped would happen... sort of?

Here we have two incontrovertible facts present;

1. All the characters saw the thief with their own eyes take the two bags of loot.
2. The thief player was directly denying that reality to the other players.

Oof. This is why we have referee responsibilities. We gotta sort this out quickly or someone is going to break the party one way or another. So, ad hoc invented mechanism time! The thief player rolled a thievery check. Other players rolled WIS checks to "detect" ... but! They were not rolling to catch the Thief in the act. Instead for each person the thief beat, we would say that his quick moves and chicanery had let him lighten the bags by 100gp each into a hidden pocket! He beat a few of the party members and secured extra loot for himself and "greed" XP later. It avoided a lengthy and destructive interparty resolution; in my opinion they could not have just worked it out in character because it was vital to one player that it happen and equally important to the others that it not. Party breaking drama would not have helped the game.

What do you think of this solution?


 GeekList Item: Item for GeekList "How Do I Check For Board Game Deals?"
Posted: Mon, 16 Nov 15:40:33

by B2TB

An item Board Game Publisher: WizKids (I) has been added to the geeklist How Do I Check For Board Game Deals?
 New comment on GeekList The 1,001: Mark's Mega-List of Games, Books, Movies, Music and More!
Posted: Mon, 16 Nov 15:26:02

by mawilson4

cicerunner wrote:

I've read the first 20 per instructions. It's whetting my appetite for Worst New to Me of 2026 when it comes out.


Heh, yeah. That's always a fun list. My worst new-to-me's this year are of course represented on this list, so I suppose it's a sneak preview for some.